How Profitable Products Can Quietly Lose Money Over Time

‍When a “Profitable” Product Quietly Loses Money 

Many eCommerce sellers run into this problem: a product sells well, looks profitable in reports, but still loses money over time. 

In most cases, the issue is not demand or competition.

It is pricing logic that does not fully account for what happens after the sale. 

This is especially common with heavy, oversized, hazmat, or high-return items. But, it can affect any product with predictable return behavior. 

The Hidden Cost Behind Returns 

Returns are often treated as exceptions. In reality, they behave like recurring costs. 

If a product is returned regularly, the cost of those returns is just as predictable as fulfillment or storage fees. Over time, every sale carries part of that cost – even if it is not visible in standard pricing calculations. 

Ignoring this is one of the main reasons products look profitable on paper but lose money in practice. 

‍

A Real-World Example 

One seller noticed that certain heavy items were returned about 1 out of every 20 orders. Each return resulted in: 

• roughly $20 in fulfillment fees 

• roughly $20 in return fees 

• occasional removal or disposal costs 

‍

Prices were competitive and sales were steady, but over time these return-related costs erased profit. The issue was not price level – it was missing cost logic. 

The Core Pricing Tip 

If an item has a high or predictable return rate, the expected return cost should be treated as part of the product’s total cost. 

Once this cost is included, pricing decisions become much clearer. 

‍

Two Practical Pricing Options 

‍

1. Add Return Costs Into the Price 

This works best when: 

• demand is stable 

• return behavior is predictable 

• protecting margin matters more than volume 

By adding expected return costs into pricing, returns no longer quietly turn the product into a loss.

2. Price Lower – Intentionally 

In some cases, lowering the price can still increase total profit.

This makes sense when: 

• lower prices significantly increase volume 

• marketplace incentives apply 

• higher sales offset return-related costs 

Before doing this, sellers should check total cost, fees, incentives, and target profit. If the math works, lower pricing is a strategy – not a risk. 

Turning Loss Patterns Into Pricing Rules 

A practical next step is turning loss insights into simple rules: 

• increase prices when fulfillment costs exceed a threshold 

• apply incentives only when profit remains positive 

This keeps pricing intentional instead of reactive. 

Turning Logic Into a System 

Doing this manually works when you have a few products. 

As catalogs grow, keeping return costs, fulfillment fees, and incentives reflected in pricing becomes harder. 

Some sellers use tools like PriceMaker to apply this logic consistently. Created by Ez Cloud, PriceMaker can automatically add a fee as a percentage of the fulfillment cost for higher-risk items and adjust price boundaries accordingly. It can also synchronize marketplace incentives, evaluating whether incentive pricing still meets profit targets before applying it. 

This helps ensure pricing reflects real costs and incentives over time, without constant manual updates or reactive price changes. 

Key Takeaways 

If a product sells well but keeps losing money, the issue is often not sales. It is missing cost logic. 

• Treat return costs as part of the total cost. 
• Choose deliberately between protecting margin or increasing volume. 
• Make sure pricing reflects how products actually perform over time. 

Pricing does not need to be perfect. It just needs to reflect reality.